Skip to main content

Playwright’s silences, minimal words, maximal cruelty consolidate for excellent Betrayal at Marin Theater

By Woody Weingarten

Emma (Liz Sklar) defensively listens to her husband, Robert (Charlie Semine).

by Woody Weingarten 

Harold Pinter sure packs a brainload into his plays. Take Betrayal, which is on stage at Marin Theatre through Nov. 15, for example.

• It’s tautly dramatic, with its pinpoint focus on a seven-year affair, predominantly in the ‘70s, between Emma, an art gallery owner played by Liz Sklar, one of the Bay Area’s top performers (who outdoes herself in expressing and not expressing a gamut of emotions), and Jerry, a literary agent portrayed with childish joy and dumbfounded detachment by Tasso Feldman.

• It’s fascinating (and occasionally a tad annoying), a mystery of sorts because it’s a tale told mostly backwards (but also forwards, in spurts) — with minimal dialogue, the playwright’s signature. It starts with a break-up and ends with a playful, lusty seduction at the affair’s beginning.

• It’s chuckle-worthy, a frequent break-the-tension necessity, with Charles Semine inhabiting the third side of the triangle, Robert, Emma’s pompous husband, a book publisher who’s long been unfaithful himself. It’s funniest when Robert engages in — what for Pinter is long — a short circular soliloquy.

• In the final analysis, though, it’s dispiriting and sad, because each main character betrays the other two.

Charlie Semine as Robert, Liz Sklar as Emma, and Tasso Feldman as Jerry.

Betrayal, a cerebral, evergreen, prize-winning play that debuted on Broadway in 1980 and has thrice been revived there, painfully explores how human beings have an innate and compulsive ability to be cruel. It surgically cuts, too, into a broad swath of concepts — self-deception, unspoken truths, power struggles, egotism, and a distortion of memories.

Silence embedded in a pause, Pinter’s best-known theatrical device, works exceedingly well in this saga of adultery that ultimately lacks either heroine or hero.

The truth is, an audience member may at times become profoundly uncomfortable knowing an all-too-real secret or lie, knowing moreover that passive viewing won’t work with this close-up portrait of three peeled human onions, that heavy listening and heavy thinking are more than occasionally required — even when the theater can be seen in a rear-view mirror.

That’s true especially if the viewer seeks certainty as to who knew what, when.

Pinter is so skilled he not only puts flesh on his main creations’ bones with amazingly skimpy but meaningful phrases, he employs perfectly a handful of offstage characters that are referenced but never seen — including Jerry’s wife, Judith; a couple of bright, young writers; and everybody’s kids.

For those who can’t cope with unlikeable characters, the recommendation would be to spend the 1¾-hour run-time doing something else that you would enjoy. If, on the other hand, dissecting relationships is your thing, be sure not to miss this production.

Tasso Feldman, Charlie Semine
The characters in the play seem painfully real despite Pinter clearly preferring sentences that are limited to five or six words and sentences that would be banal if they weren’t so brilliant. A Nobel Prize-winner, he reportedly based it on his own seven-year affair with a married BBC television personality, Joan Bakewell, while he was wed to actress Vivien Merchant, a relationship that ended up broken.

When Jerry confesses to Robert (“I was your best friend”), the latter replies ironically, “Don’t get upset. What’s the point?”

That question could be asked frequently. A voyeuristic audience member might not get immediate answers, nor immediately grok a nuanced cover-up.

At the same time, some mini-moments overflow with emotion — when Emma and Jerry split, when a letter to Emma becomes a major clue to infidelity, when Jerry simulates a teenager in lust as he seduces Emma, when her pregnancy is disclosed, and when a moving picture of a baby being tossed in the air is projected.

Carey Perloff, who has directed Pinter plays on and off since 1989, when she became his friend and worked on The Birthday Party, proves that she understands precisely what he intends the play to be, how exacting the British accents should be, and how many beats each pause should last. As a result, the ex-American Conservatory Theater director meticulously helps sculpt Betrayal characters into a production that many are likely to consider the very definition of excellence.

Photos by David Allen

Betrayal will play at the Marin Theatre, 397 Miller Ave., Mill Valley, through Nov. 15. Tickets: $39 to $110 (plus $6 handling fee per total offer). Info: 415-388-5208 or www.marintheater.org.

Woody Weingarten is an author, theatre and arts reviewer, and long-time member of the San Francisco Bay Area Theatre Critics Circle. Contact: voodee@sbcglobal.net

Betrayal

By Joseph Cillo

Betrayal at Marin Theatre

The Banality of Infidelity

There is an old saying: Time reveals all things. In Harold Pinter’s Betrayal, time does something more interesting: it runs backward. A flashback ordinarily takes us into the past to explain the present, but Pinter turns that familiar theatrical device on its head. Here, the past isn’t an occasional detour. It’s the destination.

Watching Betrayal is like peeling an onion. Each scene strips away another layer of deception, revealing what lies beneath. But Pinter’s final layer is the beginning itself. We begin with the wreckage of a love affair and travel backward toward its origins. The further back we go, the more we discover how little we understood.

Betrayal: A Story in Reverse
London, England • Venice, Italy
ACT I
1. 1977 — Pub
2. 1977 — Jerry’s study
3. 1975 — Flat
4. 1974 — Living room
ACT II
5. 1973 — Venice hotel, Italy
6. 1973 — Flat
7. 1973 — Restaurant
8. 1971 — Flat
9. 1968 — Bedroom
The ending is the beginning.

Emma is married to Robert. Jerry is Robert’s best friend—and Emma’s lover. Their affair lasts 7 years. As the story moves backward, we discover that knowledge itself has been unequally shared. Those who appear deceived may be concealing secrets of their own. The question becomes not merely who betrayed whom, but who knew what, when they knew it—and why they remained silent.

Director Carey Perloff, who worked personally with Pinter, brings a sure understanding of his distinctive theatrical language to Marin Theatre. The set is brilliantly conceived. A double bed sits on a raised platform at center stage—a proscenium altar to infidelity. There it remains, a silent witness to deception, damaged friendship, and the corrosion of trust.

The bed never moves, while time moves relentlessly backward.

Liz Sklar as Emma, Charlie Semine as Robert, and Tasso Feldman as Jerry deliver accomplished individual performances. Nic Moore completes the cast as the Waiter. Yet something curious happens when the three principals share the stage: the emotional chemistry seems to evaporate. We are watching the aftermath of a 7-year affair, but where is the passion that sustained it?

Is this a shortcoming of the production—or Pinter’s deliberate portrait of people for whom intimacy has become another form of deception?

The Banality of Betrayal

What is most unsettling is the extraordinary ordinariness of it all.

They talk. They drink. They reminisce. They betray. And life goes on.

I confess to a personal antipathy toward such casual infidelity. The destruction of trust strikes me as profoundly corrosive—not only to relationships, but to the people involved. Perhaps that is Pinter’s most disturbing insight. Betrayal need not be accompanied by grand passion, dramatic confrontation, or even much apparent guilt. It can become almost routine.

Betrayal production photographs. Photos by David Allen.

The production features excellent scenic and projection design by Yuki Izumihara, lighting by Russell Champa, sound by Fiona Sharkey, and original music by Jack Perla.

“What can you say when a love affair is over?” asks Antônio Carlos Jobim’s haunting song How Insensitive. Pinter offers an unsettling answer: Perhaps the most revealing things are those never said at all. His characters conceal as much in their pauses as in their words. An innocent question may mask a devastating truth. A casual conversation can become an exercise in mutual deception.

By the final scene—which is actually the beginning—we understand these people differently. Each revelation has changed the meaning of what came after. That is the paradox of this production: excellent acting, ingenious dramatic construction, and relationships strangely devoid of warmth. Perhaps that absence is precisely the point.

Betrayal begins with the consequences and ends with the cause. By then, Pinter has stripped away every layer of deception—leaving us to wonder whether these people ever truly knew one another.


Betrayal by Harold Pinter
Director: Carey Perloff
Through November 15
Marin Theatre, 397 Miller Avenue, Mill Valley
$39–$110, plus $6 handling fee per order
Box Office:
MarinTheatre.org
415-388-5208

Recommended for lovers of intelligent drama, psychological intrigue, and sophisticated theater.

Joe Cillo banner

Ross Valley Players’ ‘Death of a Salesman’ is tension-filled tragedy with spectacular lead actor

By Woody Weingarten


(L-R) Willy Loman, played by Charles Queary, listens to his sorrowful son, Biff, played by Brennan Pickman-Thoon, as the younger son, Happy, played by Evan Held, observes in Ross Valley Players’ production of “Death of a Salesman,” playing at the Barn Theater in Ross, Calif., through Sunday, Oct. 25, 2026. (Robin Jackson via Bay City News)

By WOODY WEINGARTEN

“Death of a Salesman” spotlights many contradictions that exist at the same time — reality and illusion, self-puffery and self-denigration, sensitivity and insensitivity, among them.

It therefore seems appropriate to quote a pair of theatergoers leaving a recent Saturday matinee of the Ross Valley Players’ production. She, a plus-one who hadn’t seen the tragedy before: “That was painful to watch.” He, a theater buff: “That was one of the best productions of anything in the Bay Area this year.”

Both agree that Charles Queary is a spectacular Willy Loman, playwright Arthur Miller’s main character in the tragedy, smoothly switching from love to anger, from hubris to confusion, and displaying a string of other emotions.

His consistent brain fog, as he descends further into what was then called senility and is now known as dementia, is symbolized by smoke rising from a set designed by Ron Krempetz that creatively features the skeleton of a house.


Howard, played by William Brosnahan, left, fires Willy Loman, played by Charles Queary, right, in Ross Valley Players’ production of “Death of a Salesman,” playing at the Barn Theater in Ross, Calif., through Sunday, Oct. 25, 2026. (Robin Jackson via Bay City News)

Willy never quite loses his mind — despite being suicidal — but does often lose himself via dreams, “daymares,” and hallucinations.

The character, in fact, is a perfect foil at age 63 for the playwright to metaphorically express disdain for capitalism and the American dream, both of which Willy and his sons believe offer most of the population false hopes before junking and crushing them.

Willy has represented a middle-class everyman since 1949, when “Death of a Salesman” debuted on Broadway with Lee J. Cobb in the role only a decade after the United States was in the midst of the Great Depression.

The Pulitzer Prize-winning play is still relevant — with a handful of striking exceptions like a reference to something costing a nickel — to a nation in which polls insist the majority is fed up with President Donald Trump’s erratic tariffs and resultant high prices at the pump and supermarket, an endless war, and over-reaching deportation policies.

This play is not the kind you might normally expect at the Barn Theater at the Marin Art and Garden Center in Ross, or any other community theater, since those audiences lean toward old-fashioned drawing-room comedies and nearly new jukebox musicals.

The evergreen drama, a Tony-winner for best play, is set in 1940s Brooklyn, with costumes by Valera Coble pulling theatergoers back there almost instantly.

Willy, after 34 years of loyalty, is fired from his traveling salesman job by Howard (played short-temperedly by William Brosnahan), the son of the man who originally hired him.

That identical 34-year timeframe is also the age of Willy’s older son, Biff (portrayed with bravado and weakness by Brennan Pickman-Thoon).

Willy’s younger son, Happy (played by Evan Held as a man who has bigger dreams for his brother than himself), fills out the male triangle in a play that at times resembles a Greek or Shakespearean tragedy.


Willy Loman, played by Charles Queary, left, borrows money from Charley, played by Steve Price, right, Loman’s neighbor and wannabe friend in Ross Valley Players’ production of “Death of a Salesman,” playing at the Barn Theater in Ross, Calif., through Sunday, Oct. 25, 2026. (Robin Jackson via Bay City News)

The crowd at the Barn becomes so spellbound that it didn’t seem to mind that two understudies are carrying scripts in their hands: Amanda Vitiello as Linda Loman, Willy’s supportive and understanding wife, and Greg Wilker as Ben, Willy’s brother who supposedly trekked into the jungle and four years later came out rich with diamonds.

But the audience does take every opportunity to periodically laugh out loud, a relief from the perpetual tension on stage.

The production’s director, Adrian Elfenbaum, keeps tons of dialogue moving so easily that nearly three hours pass without the audience craving a trim to the time length.

Miller has a knack of summing up his characters’ discontent with a few words. For instance:

• Happy, a hopeless womanizer, laments to brother Biff: “It’s what I always wanted. My own apartment, a car, and plenty of women. And still, goddammit, I’m lonely.”

• Biff opens up to his father Willy: “Why am I trying to become what I don’t want to be?”

• Willy talks to his wife Linda: “Work a lifetime to pay off a house. You finally own it, and there’s nobody to live in it.”

• Linda pleading with her sons about Willy: “Be sweet to him, be loving to him, because he’s just a little boat looking for a harbor.”

Sometimes there’s a brief soliloquy that also conveys a great deal, such as Biff talking to his younger brother about his ambivalence with the American dream: “To get on that subway on the hot mornings in summer. To devote your whole life to keeping stock, or making phone calls, or selling or buying. To suffer 50 weeks of the year for the sake of a two-week vacation, when all you really desire is to be outdoors, with your shirt off. And always to have to get ahead of the next fella. And still — that’s how you build a future.”

All things considered, this “Death of a Salesman” is surely a “must-see.”

The Ross Valley Players production of “Death of a Salesman” plays at the Barn Theater, 30 Sir Francis Drake Blvd., Ross, through Oct. 25. Tickets from $30 to $45 can be purchased online at www.rossvalleyplayers.com or calling 415-456-9555.

Woody Weingarten can be contacted via www.woodyweingarten.com or www.vitalitypress.com or www.voodee@sbcglobal.net.

National a cappella finals in Marin generate good music, comedy, memories

By Woody Weingarten

Last year’s a cappella champions, Smoke Ring, who acted as host of the 41st annual Harmony Sweepstakes.

 

By WOODY WEINGARTEN

The national finals of the 41st annual Harmony Sweepstakes, an a cappella festival, proved Saturday night just how exquisite an instrument the vocal cords of soloists for many disparate groups can be.

Ditto the blended notes, traditional and modern, of a barber shop quartet. Or those from a sextet. Or an octet. Or a 12-member ensemble.

The highly entertaining 2¼-hour event in the Marin Center’s exhibit hall was repeatedly filled with horn-like, drum-like, and bass-like human vocals. Moreover, with jazz and hip-hop and romantic ballads.

Every bit of it harmonious. With one or two moments of exception, all upbeat and fun.

If there were any doubt, all one had to do was look at virtually any face in the vanilla 600-member audience to see a perma-smile the music imprinted on it.

Their pleasure, of course, may also have been due to the absence of gangsta rap, rape allusions, and f-bombs, or political bullet points about headline violence.

The finalists, from four areas of the United States, each crammed as many songs as they could in 12 minutes. All of them made sure to insert humor.

A fifth regional winner, the Bookmarks, a mid-Atlantic sextet, was supposed to appear but was kept from attending by our federal government, which blocked members’ visas.

 

The new national a cappella champs, Linc 182.

A panel of four judges, each with a different specialty, jointly picked Linc 182, from the Chicago district, as the 2026 sweepstakes winner. The group stood out partially because its tenor was 14-year-old Lincoln Beutel, son of the baritone, Tim Beutel. The teen’s actually been singing with the quartet since he was 10.

The group showed how bouncy an a cappella song could be when it performed “My Girl.” But its most memorable tune — “When Words Fail” — was laugh-out-loud funny and poignant at the same time. It starred a single long-stemmed flower.Mountain division winners hailed, was judged to be the best regional arrangement. The five women and three men also provided something different, gospel-like vibes that included the idea of “got me in chains.”

Coda Conduct, with a dozen singers whose choreography was particularly impressive, represented the Bay Area. Some of its lyrics were muffled, unfortunately, an anomaly for the evening.

The 7th Variety, yet another barbershop quartet, this one from Orange County, was the jazziest entry, also coloring songs with its “doo dah, doo dah, do wop” trope. Their top lyric centered on a long search for “a major chord.”

The show’s emcee was Paul Nathan, who’s appeared on HBO and in Eddie Murphy’s film, Dr. Doolittle. He inserted his own brand of cleverness and prestidigitation — and used a competition cliché when announcing the winners. It was really close, said the balding, salt-and-pepper-bearded guy.

That, in truth, was no surprise because all the groups had signature pieces that were outstanding.

Nathan’s schtick was accented playfully by a little girl named Alice that he invited on stage as a stooge for his magic tricks. Although the emcee was skillful, the kid turned out to be funnier — especially when she tried to high-five him as he towered over her.

“Special guests.” from Sacramento, were Outta the Vox, who had been an opening act for Foreigner. Their finger-snapping was unique, as was the “time-keeper” at the end of their line whose always in-motion right hand sometime resembled a beat-box tool, sometimes an air-guitar.

The crowd went wild, meanwhile, when the 11 group members performed “Jolene” as a foot-stomping tribute to the recently deceased Dolly Parton, proof that a country tune about husband-stealing can fit well into an a cappella gathering.

But perhaps the best group to perform was last year’s national champs, Smoke Ring, a mixed voice barbershop and contemporary a cappella quartet based in New York. They wore tight black costumes with an abundance of leather, the most striking outfits to appear on stage (men of many groups wore boring suits ties, and vests, with the women clad in floor-length skirts or gowns).

The Harmony Sweepstakes was the original brainstorm of San Anselmo-based John Neal, now president of Primarily A Cappella, “the nation’s leading vendor of a cappella music including recordings, arrangements, DVDs, songbooks and instructional material for singers.”

All told, he can be held responsible for truckloads of good music and comedy and memories. Enough of each, in fact, to last a year, until the 42nd annual sweepstakes rolls around.

Woody Weingarten, a longtime voting member of the San Francisco Bay Area Theater Critics Circle, can be contacted via his website, https://woodyweingarten.com, his email — voodee@sbcglobal.net — or his other website, https://vitalitypress.com. His four books include Rollercoaster: How a caregiver can survive a partner’s breast cancer or any other lethal disease; MysteryDates — How to keep the sizzle in your relationship; The Roving I, a compilation of 70 of his newspaper columns; and Grampy and His Fairyzona Playmates, a whimsical fantasy intended for 6- to 10-year-olds that he co-authored with his then 8-year-old granddaughter.

John Turturro plays sad, sensitive, uptight pickpocket in new suspenseful crime film

By Woody Weingarten

John Turturro as Harry in The Only Living Pickpocket in New York.

By WOODY WEINGARTEN

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York is easy to review — because it features a tour de force performance by John Turturro, famed for his understated roles in Coen Brothers and Spike Lee films and for his Emmy-winning tenure on the TV series Monk.

For the full hour and 28 minutes of this new gritty crime drama, he, as low-level pickpocket Harry Lehman, is either shifty-eyed or fearful but either way, moviegoers aren’t expected to lift their eyes from him.

So we watch in awe as his hands slip into a variety of pockets while he surreptitiously watches everyone else. And we witness the jumpstart of his real trouble shortly after he lifts an apparently valuable USB drive from Dylan, wealthy Gen-Z son of a mob boss.

It’s unclear what’s on it, but it’s clear that Dylan and his cronies want it back. Desperately.

The wild, menacing young men threaten him, saying “there’s no comin’ back from this,” and then also threaten his “old lady” if the USB stick isn’t returned — a trigger for a frenzied do-or-die backtracking with a series of offbeat characters, including Steve Buscemi as Benny, pawnbroker/friend and fence.

During that journey, viewers revel in shots of New York City, not the predictable shots of the Statue of Liberty, Empire State Building, and Brooklyn and George Washington bridges but, instead, extraordinary shots of ordinary neighborhoods in each of the city’s five boroughs, images that truly provide a sense of the city.

Those insightful views contrast sharply with, at the beginning of the lyrics of a song that softly blankets the action, “New York, I love you, but you’re bringing me down.”

The suspensefully hypnotic film, which has several twists, is not without humor — such as when Harry meaningfully sits on his hands while talking and laughing with longtime friend, NYPD Detective Allan Warren (played by Giancarlo Esposito), and even more so when he catches a wannabe crook trying to pick the pocket of his expensive cashmere coat. He grabs the guy’s hand and instantly gives him a tutorial in how to do it right.

Turturro, who many believe will be nominated for an Oscar for this role, which would be his first nomination, runs a gamut of emotions as an old-style pickpocket struggling to make ends meet.

He is sad, for instance, because his potential marks no longer carry wads of cash but only credit cards that can typically be cancelled with little disruption of their lives. And they wear Timex-priced watches instead of Rolexes.

He is extremely loving, poignant, and uptight when dealing with his bedridden, disabled wife, Rosie (Karina Arroyave). He carries her up the stairs when their building’s elevator is on the blink. He holds her hands, brushes her hair, talks to her even though she can’t talk back, cooks noodle soup. And when he goes out, he pays a neighbor to look after her.

Turturro, a native of Brooklyn, and Harry, who’s being digitally stalked, complement each other.

Says Harry in the Sony Pictures Classics film that’s deftly directed by Noah Segan, “I’ve had a good life…What matters is what you did with the time you had. I spent my life in people’s pockets.”

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, elaborates Turturro, is a “tense kind of thriller…and at the same time…all this human delicacy and gentleness.”

The movie, the world premiere of which was at Sundance, where it was a crowd favorite, was also shown at the recent Mill Valley Film Festival. It’s scored in the high 90th percentile for both critics and public on the Rotten Tomatoes website.

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York will have a free Bay Area screening at a 7 p.m. Oct. 21 AARP event, for which registration is required, and will screen the same day at the Sonoma International Film Festival. It will open in Los Angeles and New York City on Oct. 23, and across the country Oct. 30, including AMC Metreon 16 in San Francisco, AMC Bay Street 16 in Emeryville, and Cinemark Century Daily City.

Woody Weingarten, a longtime voting member of the San Francisco Bay Area Theater Critics Circle, can be contacted via his website, https://woodyweingarten.com, his email — voodee@sbcglobal.net — or his other website, https://vitalitypress.com. His four books include Rollercoaster: How a caregiver can survive a partner’s breast cancer or any other lethal disease; MysteryDates — How to keep the sizzle in your relationship; The Roving I, a compilation of 70 of his newspaper columns; and Grampy and His Fairyzona Playmates, a whimsical fantasy intended for 6- to 10-year-olds that he co-authored with his then 8-year-old granddaughter.

Surreal, serious Berkeley show is chaotic, humorous, tender — and well worth seeing

By Woody Weingarten

One of countless surreal moments in The Fall Show. Photo by Ben Krantz.

By WOODY WEINGARTEN

The marquee of the Ashby Stage in Berkeley gives away what the premiere performance of The Fall Show is all about: A surreal love story.

The theatrical mosaic leaps again and again from imaginative prop to unusually choreographed movement, often successfully exhibiting chaos and mania.

And it’s accented as if famed Belgian artist René Magritte snuck in and taught the actors how to recreate his famous paintings in living form.

Didn’t happen. The show’s the joint work of playwright “Chuck” Mee, who specializes in collage-like constructs, and skillful co-creator/director/choreographer Erika Chong Shuch. They’d swear, in fact, they created it rather than wrote it, across the country from each other, as the unique project evolved. Mee was in New York mostly providing stage directions and Shuch was in San Francisco sculpting the production. They “talked” by text.

So, start with such visual and sound tidbits as actors tossing around piles of maple leaves, smashing multiple plates (with joyous anger), and raising enough voices to become a symphony of screams.

Add an almost linear storyline with two older, lonely main characters, Eddie and Sam, inhabited by remarkable, mostly-understated actors, Beth Wilmurt (replete with AARP magazine) and Reginald Wilkins (replete with purposeful indecision). Their energy contrasts exquisitely with the crazed, most often in-motion group of six that surrounds them, a couple sporting Magritte-like black derby hats.

Tender moment between Reginald Wilkins (Sam) and Beth Wilburn (Eddie).

Her aggressiveness contrasts with his being laid back. Fodder enough for a volatile, tenuous relationship? Perfect for any audience member who wants to relate to his, hers, or their own? Yep!

Each member of the ensemble seems well cast, by the way, none more so than longtime Joe Goode dancer Marit Brook-Kothlow, who best shows her chops in a set-piece of improvised wildness in an improvised, oversized couch.

Need more minutia?

Maybe your seatmate knows why the center-stage barren tree has one green leaf near its peak. Or why an onstage pianist is pounding out German composerLudwig van Beethoven at his loudest. Or why four doors keep opening and slamming? Or why it’s necessary for a leaf-blower to aim at human beings.

Or how Wilmurt, who’s also the music director and vocal arranger, is able to so smoothly insert recorded tunes that so delightfully mesh with what’s on stage. Or why it’s necessary to learn how not to lie.

What there isn’t is cliches or bumper stickers or many f- bombs. What there is are burnt toast and burnt barbecue gloves; one of the longest intentional pauses ever seen on stage; a mic cord that can morph into a sexual device; the genderless, race-ignored crew that also tests out loving relationships and may (or may not) represent the inner thoughts and feelings of the couple; plus lots of hidden-meaning stuff and familiar objects in unfamiliar contexts (yeah, there’s Magritte again).

Ergo, the show should contain enough wonderment and puzzlement to drag the most curious theatergoers back for another shot or two at figuring everything out.

Enough clever humor is sprinkled throughout to keep the biggest sourpuss grinning, but underneath the slapstick and weirdness can be found a hyper-serious examination of an honest but iffy relationship.

And just a smidgeon of sadness.

But despite world of tumult and human-heart difficulties, these words keep bouncing around in a viewer’s mind: tender, sweet, brilliant.

And the Ashby Stage marquee displays three others that summarize a good deal: Music. Movement. Magic.

Go! Enjoy!

The Fall Show will run on the Ashby Stage, 1901 Ashby Ave., Berkeley, through Nov. 1 (it was extended). Tickets: $40 to $80. Info:(https://shotgunplayers.org) or 510-841-6500.

Woody Weingarten, a longtime voting member of the San Francisco Bay Area Theater Critics Circle, can be contacted via his website, https://woodyweingarten.com, his email — voodee@sbcglobal.net — or his other website, https://vitalitypress.com. His four books include Rollercoaster: How a caregiver can survive a partner’s breast cancer or any other lethal disease; MysteryDates — How to keep the sizzle in your relationship; The Roving I, a compilation of 70 of his newspaper columns; and Grampy and His Fairyzona Playmates, a whimsical fantasy intended for 6- to 10-year-olds that he co-authored with his then 8-year-old granddaughter.

“The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance” at Meadow Brook Theater, Rochester Hills MI

By Greg & Suzanne Angeo

Reviewed by Suzanne Angeo (Member, American Theatre Critics Association)

and Greg Angeo (Member Emeritus, San Francisco Bay Area Theatre Critics Circle)

 

Photos courtesy of Sean Carter Photography

Fresh Take on Mythos of the Old West

So you may think you know all about “The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance”;  you’ve seen the famous 1962 John Ford movie with Jimmy Stewart, John Wayne and Lee Marvin, right?

Boy, have you got another think coming.

The spellbinding tale unfolding on Meadow Brook Theatre’s stage, kicking off their 60th season, bears very little resemblance to the one on the silver screen. While Ford’s film used Dorothy M Johnson’s 1949 short story merely as inspiration, the 2014 stage adaptation by British writer, producer and director Jethro Compton is much more faithful to Johnson’s original material.

“Liberty Valance” takes place in the small town of Twotrees in the fading years of the Old West, in an unnamed territory, entirely inside The Prairie Belle Saloon. It addresses frontier justice, politics, class inequality, racism, gun violence and societal change in ways that are both of the times, and timely. A touchingly bittersweet surprise at the end will linger in your memory long after you’ve left the theater.

Chris Blisset, Brandon Ruiteer

The story opens in 1910, with the famous Senator Foster arriving in town for the funeral of an old friend. There are pallbearers, mourners, and a singing guitar player that serves as a narrator, helping to tell the story from scene to scene.

The rest of the tale is told in flashback. We travel back in time 25 years earlier, and find the ruff n’ tuff young lady saloon keeper, Hallie Jackson, owner of The Prairie Belle Saloon. Her admirer, burly bearded Bert Barricune, hangs around to lend a hand. And there’s Jim, AKA “The Reverend”, a gifted young Black man who works at the saloon but dreams of bigger things. One day Burt carries in an unconscious young man and deposits him on the bar. Hallie tends to his wounds and cleans him up. When he awakens, he says he’s looking for the guys who beat him up and left him for dead on the deserted plains. He is Ransome Foster, and he has traveled all the way from NYC to find a new way of life. He apparently is well-educated, with law books in his backpack.

Bert recognizes Foster’s description of the attackers – it’s the notorious Liberty Valance, malevolence personified, and his gang of thugs. The local authority, Marshall Johnson, is summoned. Foster plans his revenge, but days turn into weeks, and soon he comes to feel very much at home in his new town. A growing attraction between himself and Hallie makes him want to stay even more, much to Bert’s dismay.

Marley Boone

Many townsfolk, including Hallie, Jim and Bert, are illiterate. Foster offers to start a class in the saloon to teach them how to read, and tries to introduce some culture to Hallie. She has captured his heart, despite her rough exterior and coarse talk. Who could ever know these innocent gestures might lead to trouble and heartbreak, and to a standoff between good versus evil with the highest stakes imaginable?

Brandon Ruiter as Foster delivers an impressive performance of a daring and heroic character, willing to sacrifice himself for love and honor. Hallie, the crusty saloon keeper with a tender heart, is played to spunky, lively perfection by MBT newcomer Marley Boone.

The title role is played by Drew Parker, another MBT newbie, who has performed all over the country. His Valance has sinister qualities simmering just below the surface.

Drew Parker, Brandon Ruiter

Barricune is played by the marvelous MBT veteran Stephen Blackwell. A real showstopper (and scene stealer), he commands the stage in a role that, in the end, serves as the true North Star of the story.

The amazing Tyrick Wiltez Jones brings his strong Broadway chops to the unforgettable role of Jim (“The Reverend”). Marshall Johnson is played by Phil Powers, another MBT regular, with a powerful stage presence.

The Narrator is performed by the multi-talented Chris Blisset, who plays guitar and sings folksy period songs that help to tell the story. This award-winning actor, writer and director (and musician-singer!) captures the very essence of the time and place. A very nice touch, indeed!

The intricate yet rustic two-level set by Mia Irwin has a big job to do, since it’s all we see and know of the town of Twotrees. It’s helped along with lighting by Griffen Proctor, which transforms the set to highlight different situations. Day changes to night and back again, sundown to sunup, and chiaroscuro effects spotlight dramatic scenes.

Director (and long-time MBT Creative Director) Travis Walter, as always, interprets the script, makes thoughtful choices, and guides the actors to give us wonderful storytelling. He keeps us captivated from the very beginning, on the edge of our seats, as the story propels us to a beautifully ironic conclusion with nary a slow spot to be found. But be prepared: there’s lots of very salty dialogue, and a couple of gunshots. Which is what you’d expect in the Old West.

Please note new 7:30 PM evening start times for this season!

When: Now through November 1, 2026

Tickets $43 to $49

Where: Meadow Brook Theatre at Wilson Hall

Oakland University

378 Meadow Brook Rd

Rochester Hills, MI 48309

(248) 377-3300

www.mbtheatre.com

This production is made possible through the generous support of the Fred and Barbara Erb Family Foundation, the Shubert Foundation and the Meadow Brook Theatre Guild.

Meadow Brook Theatre is a professional theatre located on the campus of Oakland University in Rochester, Michigan. MBT is a nonprofit cultural institution serving southeast Michigan for 60 years

Smuin Ballet offers two ‘truly awesome’ revivals, one experiment in San Francisco

By Woody Weingarten

Amy Seiwert

 

 

Michael Smuin

 

 

By WOODY WEINGARTEN

“French Kiss,” choreographed by artistic director Amy Seiwert in 2023, was the definitive hit of the San Francisco Opening Night concert of Smuin Contemporary Ballet, if Friday’s level of applause is used as a measuring device.

The light-hearted, liquid, and lovely dance — note-perfect to the music of Pink Martini — was smooth as satin yet filled with flavors: romantic, dramatic, traditional, modern, and hilarious.

It encompassed smile-inducing lifts and circles as well as sexy flashes and rather unusual butts-extended moments.

Best received was a comic sequence in which two manikins atop small platforms on wheels were pushed around by a pair of dancers.

Pink Martini is an eclectic American band that embraces jazz, classical, Latin, and pop — in 15 languages.

Seiwert, in the program, writes that the ballet pays homage to the “signature style” of company founder Michael Smuin, who died two decades ago, by being “rich in characterization” and celebrating “the individuality of Smuin’s dancers.”

In Friday’s introduction, Seiwert flippantly claimed her “French Kiss” crammed in “all I learned from Michael in 25 minutes.”

The presentation, in addition to loud applause, drew a hailstorm of encouraging and appreciative “woo” cries from the audience.

Another truly awesome revival, “Stabat Mater,” was a Michael Smuin creation that dated to 2002 and was choreographed to the music of Antonin Dvořák. It hadn’t been staged in the Bay Area in 10 years.

That stupendous ballet was Smuin’s dramatic response to the “death and pain” of 9/11 and featured lots of female bodies trustingly falling into the arms of male dancers. It met its intention of exploring “loss, the resilience of community, and, ultimately, hope.”

The third part of the concert was new — an experimental dance-salad choreographed by My’Kal Stromile, a triple threat who also was responsible for the costumes and stage design. It was, however, as odd as its title, “I-Scrit-Ah-Scree-Tah-Skratt,” which is an invented phonetic phrase, and almost as opaque as the choreographer’s official explanation in obfuscation-speak.

Its music was by Wilhem Friedemann Bach, the oldest son of Johann Sebastian Bach, replete with choral that’s a knock-out.

Still, most of the dance segments felt as if they were unfinished fragments, perhaps intentionally. Some concertgoers, in fact, probably found it difficult to perceive exactly what was being portrayed.

In contrast, the company’s program was enlightening in many ways. It showed, for instance, how many behind-the-scenes people are necessary to keep the dancers in good shape. It listed a wellness team with eight orthopedic and physical therapy doctors, three chiropractors, four acupuncturists, and two massage therapists.

All, of course, were also available to keep the company healthy for previous performances in Mountain View and Walnut Creek.

Obviously, it’s worth any trouble.

French Kiss will run at the 437-seat waterfront Cowell Theater at Fort Mason, 2 Marina Blvd., San Francisco, through Oct. 18. Tickets: $25 to $100. Info: 415-912-1899 or boxoffice@smuinballet.org.

Woody Weingarten, a longtime voting member of the San Francisco Bay Area Theater Critics Circle, can be contacted by email at voodee@sbcglobal.net or on his websites, https://woodyweingarten.com and https://vitalitypress.com. His books include Rollercoaster: How a caregiver can survive a partner’s breast cancer or any other lethal disease; MysteryDates — How to keep the sizzle in your relationship; The Roving I, a compilation of 70 of his newspaper columns; and Grampy and His Fairyzona Playmates, a whimsical fantasy intended for 6- to 10-year-olds that he co-authored with his then 8-year-old granddaughter.

 

Peter Pan Goes Wrong

By Joe Cillo, Joseph Cillo

 


Non-stop comedic chaos — brilliantly executed.

There is an old theatrical saying: The show must go on.

In Peter Pan Goes Wrong, that turns out to be less an inspirational thought than a threat.

The Cornley Drama Society sets out to perform Peter Pan. They have the actors, costumes, scenery and flying equipment. What they don’t seem to have is any reasonable chance of reaching the final curtain without disaster.

And that is exactly what makes it so funny.

Director Susi Damilano keeps the production moving at a terrific pace. Missed cues, rebellious props, disastrous flying and increasingly desperate performers pile one catastrophe upon another.

The ensemble commits completely to the madness. Ezra Reaves, as Jonathan playing Peter Pan, tackles Peter’s increasingly unreliable airborne adventures with wonderful determination. Jomar Tagatac, as Chris, president of the Cornley Drama Society, grows increasingly desperate to maintain control of a production that refuses to cooperate.

Peter Pan Goes Wrong production slideshow. Photos by Jessica Palopoli.

The company understands the essential rule of farce: Never play the joke. Play the disaster.

The physical comedy is superbly controlled.

Erin Rose Solorio’s choreography, Bridgette Loriaux’s flying work, Dani O’Dea’s fight and stunt direction, and Patrick Russell’s clowning expertise combine with Damilano’s direction to make catastrophe look spontaneous.

Actors fall, collide, fly and recover. Props misbehave. Technical cues become jokes.

Every apparent mistake has to be the right mistake.

The flying is especially funny. Instead of hiding the machinery and making Peter’s flight look effortless, this production turns getting him into the air — and back down again — into part of the comedy.

And then there is Cody Tellis Rutledge’s ingenious three-segment revolving set.

It becomes another member of the cast.

Doors, walls, levels and moving sections become part of the comedy as the set carries us through Neverland.

By the finale, it seems to take over the production.

It begins turning faster. Then faster. Then faster still.

Sitting in the audience, I began wondering just how far they were going to take it.

For a few wonderful moments, it seemed entirely possible that the set was going to spin the actors right off the stage and into our laps.

It is a wonderfully funny finish to an evening in which the cast, physical comedy and stagecraft work together with remarkable precision.

The more everything goes wrong, the funnier it gets.

Peter Pan Goes Wrong is fast, physical, inventive and wonderfully performed. It makes theatrical incompetence look effortless.

Go. Laugh. And enjoy watching everything go spectacularly wrong.


PETER PAN GOES WRONG
San Francisco Playhouse

By Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer and Henry Shields
Directed by Susi Damilano

Through November 28, 2026

Performance Schedule:
Tuesdays and Thursdays: 7:00 PM
Wednesdays: 2:00 PM & 7:00 PM
Fridays: 8:00 PM
Saturdays: 2:00 PM & 8:00 PM
Sundays: 2:00 PM

San Francisco Playhouse
450 Post Street
San Francisco, CA

Tickets: $52–$145


Recommended if you enjoy fast-paced farce, physical comedy and theatrical mayhem.

Joe Cillo banner

‘Legally Blonde’ at Berkeley Playhouse is energetic, funny, and as sugary as cotton candy

By Woody Weingarten

 

Jump-rope dance is a showstopper in ‘Legally Blonde The Musical’ at the Berkeley Playhouse. Photo copyright Thomas Campitelli/Berkeley Playhouse.

By WOODY WEINGARTEN

Choreography by Cat Delos Santos Reyes, often sidesplittingly funny, usually with the highest energy possible, became the primo star of the Berkeley Playhouse’s presentation of Legally Blonde The Musical.

A dance between two gay men, in fact, was once of three showstoppers at a recent Sunday matinee that drew full-throated laughs, roaring cheers, and heavy applause.

In-sync jump-rope dancing to “Whipped into Shape” was a definite eye popper that didn’t stop, and three damsels in white togas representing a Greek chorus emerged as the epitome of silliness.

Elizabeth Curtis, in the role of Paulette, hair stylist with a hard edge, a soft heart, and a longing for Ireland,  ran a musical gamut from hilarious to poignant. “She’s funnier than Jennifer Coolidge was in the  movie,” an older woman in the audience called to after one bit.

Curtis showed off her comic chops in both solo bits and in conjunction with Adam Mendez Jr. as Kyle, a burly UPS deliveryman who stalked her lovingly i the second act. Rollickingly amusing!

Vivienne, portrayed perfectly by the mellifluous singer Grace Margaret Craig, was the character who changed the most — from snarky, stuck-up boyfriend poacher to warm activist supporter of females.

Major diversity in actors’ size and skin color was a definite plus.

The central character, Elle Woods, pink-garbed UCLA sorority sister cum Harvard Law student who finds ways to do things her individualistic way and still succeed, normally steals the show. Here, however, Ayani Dorsey’s high-pitched voice didn’t fit her mic well so her words — sung and spoken — were often difficult to make out.

Although the dark-skinned Dorsey wore a curl-heavy blonde wig and a perma-smile through most of the campy two-act, two-hour show, she didn’t quite inject the quirkiness remembered from the fire-cracking Reese Witherspoon role in the original 2007 film comedy.

And while male characters’ tones were clear because of their lower registers, difficulty discerning lyrics also happened in several chorus numbers (though amazing dance moves tended to overshadow that flaw).

Elle Woods (Ayana Dorsey, center) celebrates an insight as her sorority sisters egg her on. Photo copyright by Thomas Campitelli/Berkeley Playhouse.

 

 

 

Humor, from Heather Hach’s book, was frequent. And — yippie! — none of the jokes depended on f-bombs.

Welcome too, drawing smiles each time they were on stage, were too pooches: Latke, a Pomeranian normally carried in Elle’s purse and dubbed Bruiser in the show, and Stella, a French bulldog mix who, as Rufus, was trotted around by Kyle. Neither yipped nor barked, neither wet or soiled the stage. Good doggies! Instagram — quick!

Hey, don’t make the mistake thinking Legally Blonde is only fluff ‘n’ stuff and as sugary as cotton candy.  Underlying the unsubtle modern fairytale are questions of feminism and sexism, identity, self-worth, authenticity, and how to navigate a relationship — all tucked neatly into a musical extravaganza spotlighting glitzy costumes by Ashlee Renee and fast-moving backdrops by scenic designer Sarah Phykitt (including an imaginative center-stage door to nowhere).

No’eau Kahalekulu, in her main stage directorial debut, makes sure everything moves at a lightning pace, with exceptions like “Blood in the Water,” a brooding satire that illustrates how lawyers become sharks.

The musical, which opened on Broadway in 2007, contains 20 numbers including three reprises), staring with the incredibly bouncy “Oh My God.” They’re mainly jukebox pop tunes with touches of hip-hop — music and lyrics by Laurence O’Keefe and Nell Benjamin — virtually guaranteed to make theatergoers feel good.

Proof? Well, a raft of pre-pubescent girls who filled about ut a third of the seats happily chatted up a storm while shaking their bottoms and hips in the aisles as they left.

Legally Blonde The Musical will run at the Berkeley Playhouse, 2640 College Ave., Berkeley, through Oct. 18 (it’s been extended). Tickets: $19 to $56 (plus a $3.95 ticketing fee). Info: 510-845-8542 or www.berkeleyplayouse.org.