Reviewed by Suzanne Angeo (Member, American Theatre Critics Association)
and Greg Angeo (Member Emeritus, San Francisco Bay Area Theatre Critics Circle)
Photos courtesy of Sean Carter Photography
A Sparkling Valentine to the Theatre
The Angel Next Door (also known as Theater People) was adapted by noted American playwright Paul Slade Smith from a classic play by Ferenc Molnar called Play at the Castle. It premiered in September 2023 at the North Coast Repertory Theatre in Solana Beach CA. Meadow Brook Theatre is one of the first to produce this version of the show, and it’s easy to see it ending up on Broadway. An uproarious comedy with a sweet surprise and a small act of heroism lurking at its heart, it takes off like a shiny new rocket and never comes down.
The time: 1948, the place: Newport, Rhode Island. We see a sprawling set, furnished like a huge, luxurious bedroom in one of those so-called “cottages” with glorious views of the ocean. Enter Charlotte (Charley) and Arthur Sanders, a married couple in their golden years who happen to be legendary playwrights. They also happen to be a bit down on their luck, but have written a brand-new original script for what they hope will be a hit Broadway show. Tagging along is their young novelist friend, Oliver Adams, who wrote the story upon which the play is based. Oliver says his book, “The Angel Next Door” is all about his fiancée, and insists that’s just what she is…so pure and simple, lovely in every way.
It turns out his “Angel” is the beautiful actress Margot Bell, who as luck would have it, is staying in the adjoining room. Charley and Arthur are over the moon that Ollie and Margot are engaged. They introduced the young couple at a party over a year ago. Now that Ollie has written his book, they have written their play with Margot in mind, and planned on offering the part to her during their stay. Trouble is, Ollie has been exaggerating a bit, as they soon find out. There are complications. And the walls, it seems, are very thin. To Ollie’s dismay, it becomes obvious Margot is, um, “entertaining” a handsome Broadway star in her room. In a stroke of genius, Charley comes up with a secret plan to save the day. Will the ruse work? Will Oliver be happy again? What follows is one of the best and funniest shows at MBT in recent memory, and that’s really saying something.
The script is top notch and the casting is impeccable. MBT veterans Mary Robin Roth as Charley, and Phil Powers as Arthur, have crackling chemistry between them, matching the snappy dialogue. Not to be outdone, Cheryl Turski as the surly housekeeper Olga nearly steals the show every time she’s onstage, with her uncertain accent and inhospitable hospitality. The innocent and romantic Ollie is played with winsome charm by Chris Stinson. He carries most of the emotional burden in the show with delicate finesse, balancing his comedy chops and dramatic skills. Then we have the lovely love of Ollie’s life, Margot, played with giddy panache by the equally lovely Olivia Ursu. She exudes a Betty Grable-like glamour tempered with goofy earnestness. Her amorous companion Victor, a hammy theatrical baritone, is played by the intensely charismatic David Aron Damane. He commandeers the stage like a Howard Keel type (think Kiss Me, Kate).
In a show about the theatre, it’s vital to have great stagecraft, and Angel doesn’t disappoint, with lighting by Neil Koivu and scenic design by Donna Beagle. Charley and Margot get to wear some pretty gorgeous duds when dress-up time comes along, courtesy of costume designer Marley Boone. And also a great director – Travis Walter’s love for the theatre is apparent in big and small ways. From the broad physical comedy to the tenderly poignant, this is one of his strongest, and best efforts in recent years.
Impressive cast, excellent script, nonstop laughs…is there any reason NOT to see The Angel Next Door?
Recommended for audience members in high school and up
When: Now through March 9, 2025
Tickets $39 to $48
Where: Meadow Brook Theatre at Wilson Hall
Oakland University
378 Meadow Brook Rd
Rochester Hills, MI 48309
(248) 377-3300
www.mbtheatre.com
This production is made possible through the generous support of the Michigan Arts and Cultural Council, the National Endowment for the Arts, the Fred and Barbara Erb Family Foundation, the Shubert Foundation and the Meadow Brook Theatre Guild.
Meadow Brook Theatre is a professional theatre located on the campus of Oakland University in Rochester, Michigan. MBT is a nonprofit cultural institution serving southeast Michigan for more than 58 years.