Skip to main content

“La Tragédie de Carmen” at Merola Program

By Carol Benet

“La Tragédie de Carmen” at Merola Program

Carol Benet

The 2026 Merola Summer Festival presents the first of the two operas, “La Tragédie de Carmen”, on July 9 and July 11.

This is the Peter Brook’s reinterpretation of Bizet’s masterpiece, an opera that has lasted for decades and is one of the most produced at all opera companies. Peter Brook was the enfant terrible of the theater and film director who, based in Paris, changed the way the traditional masterpieces that he created to those that exemplified his idea of “empty space”, a pared down version. Before his death in 2022 he created plays, operas, films from 1943 through 2013.

The Merola participants presented an 80 minute without intermission opera on a bare stage highlighted with wonderful projections (Camilla Task). The principal cast of seven was substituted for what is usually a crowded, busy with movement, chorus, dance in a many peopled version. Brook’s “Carmen” consists of the most famous arias and duets and whips along with what the Merola portrays as a psychological drama about Carmen (Ariana Maubach) and Don José (Charles Styles) tragic relationship.

Starting with the sweet Micaëla’s (Anna Thompson) message to the Don from his mother, it is evident that she loves him but this is unrequited as he is fixated one the beautiful and tempestuous romani Carmen who has other suitors that arouses his jealousy. The suiitors are the bullfighter Escamillo (Raül Morales Velazco), Zuniga (Ryan Bryce Johnson) along with John Mburu as Garcia and Logan Wagner as the bartender Lillas Pastia.

Mezzo-soprano Ariana Maubach as Carmen and tenor Charles Styles as Don José.
Photo credit: Kristen Loken


A former Merola ’09 winner Stephanie Rhodes Russell conducts the fine Marius Constant chamber orchestra, with some chosen from the SF Ballet as is gifted harpist Annabelle Taubl plus the pianist a current Merola artist Deven Shah at the piano. The Brook idea of adding a recording of Bizet’s Overture is an innovation.

The director Mo Zhou (Merola ’15) was inspired by Buddhist scripture in this version of Carmen with its ideas of the reoccurrence of the Don’s love for Carmen and his eternal desire for what he cannot possess.

The Merola participants for “Carmen” are ready for their professional careers as they are excellent singers and convincing actors as well. In the future we will see them often on the opera stages worldwide.

The second Merola opera this summer is Ricardo Strauss’ “Ariadne aug Naxos” on July 30 and August 1. The operas takes place at the Caroline H. Hume Concert Hall at the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, 50 Oak Street near Davies Symphony Hall. Tickets merola.org or box office 415 864 3330.

‘Hollywood Does Abortion’ documentary covers half-century of progress and retreat

By Woody Weingarten

Screenshot from Hollywood Does Abortion documentary shows protest outside clinic.

By WOODY WEINGARTEN

Hollywood Does Abortion is all about Tinseltown not wanting to do them. Or eventually caving and depicting the issue through a right-of-center lens.

The one-hour, 39-minute documentary traces a controversial topic that’s appeared more and more frequently over the decades on bigger home screens and smaller movie-house surfaces. From troubled pre-Roe vs. Wade days through today’s troubled post-Dobbs times. Political progress and retreat.

It features what feels like hundreds of quick cuts — clip after clip from flicks and telecasts and newscasts, plus tons of heads that won’t stop talking. Producers and writers and analysts and you-name-its.

Virtually every position on the subject is explored a bit, so a viewer can’t escape learning something unlearned before.

The dense panorama begins with Norman Lear’s TV heroine Maude shoving history forward by contemplating an abortion, and the public backlash that series generated; it ends with a monotone thought-balloon that we should all be tolerant and try to make the world a little better; and detours along the way for gossip and a peek at Marilyn Monroe’s abortion or miscarriage or whatever that momentary headline-grabbing, national trauma was.

The film — which was executive produced by Rachel Bloom, who will be honored July 18 at with the Freedom of Expression Award at the 46th San Francisco Jewish Film Festival — is interesting but not compelling. That may be due to its being somewhat choppy (fragmented, if you will) and mostly chronological.

Bloom, activist and co-creator and acting star of the CW musical/comedy/drama series Crazy Ex-Girlfriend, probably couldn’t care less what critics say about Hollywood Does Abortion because, after having helped spearhead the pet project, it’s now out there, at festivals at least, and from her standpoint, the more publicity, the better.

But the doc isn’t unlike a high-school class in gender politics, emphasizing multiple historic pivots as if they were tiny subheads.

Showing dramatized pre-surgical exam is screenshot from Hollywood Does Abortion.

It flits, for example, from Dirty Dancing and its branding abortion as dangerous, whether illegal or not; to Evangelicals getting heavily involved politically; to Operation Rescue with its attacks on abortion clinics and doctors; to the era of folks again wanting the procedure to disappear under the rug and be safe, legal, and rare; to a tribute to Grey’s Anatomy and how consistent the TV series has been regarding a sensitive coverage of the subject; to the not unexpected reversal of Roe; to the evolution of abortion via a welcomed pill; to the rise of streaming and its shedding of pressures from corporate bigwigs and advertisers.

Hollywood Does Abortion, which has no explosions or car chases or, indeed, any action whatsoever, sidetracks momentarily into the evolution of gay relationships on screen, and to a dozen other headline topics. That’s its biggest flaw, trying too hard to do too much.

But there’s so much content — content that appears to change every second and a half — that pro-abortion activists can find plenty to love. And to hate.

Ditto, anti-abortionists.

Either way, it’s an immersive, mildly intriguing under-two-hour mental road-trip from that Maude show in the fall of 1972 to now.

Picturing happy post-birth, on screenshot from Hollywood Does Abortion, shows how Tinseltown and TV skirt controversial issue.

Merola “L’Amina Napoletana”

By Carol Benet

Merola “L’Anima Napoletana” 

For All Events

Carol Benet

The recital of the 2026 Merola Summer Festival, “L’Anima Napoletana”, was a joyous event with 13 Merolini participants presenting a three part program of  enchanting solos and duets with piano accompaniment.  

Taking place at the San Francisco Conservatory of Music Caroline H. Hume Concert Hall at 50 Oak Street, San Francisco, it was almost a sold-out  event.  This summer’s winners of the Merola Opera training program chose 28 talented singers, accompanists, coaches, conductors  and directors out of 1500 applicants. It is a prized institution associated with the San Francisco Opera that has instruction not only in musical presentation but in the development of the artists in leadership, financial planning, mental and physical wellness, public relations and branding.  The Merola is the only young artist program to provide support for five years after participation and offers aid for essential career development. 

Thirteen artists from this summer’s program presented the music of southern Italy with themes for the three parts as little scenes.  In part one soprano Stella FitzGerald and tenor Mcllquham tell their story of young love. The 7 songs sung in local dialect translated on screens above the stage have two accomplished accompanists, Deven Shah for 5 songs and Sakurako Jayne Abe for two.

The first two songs are familiar ballads, “Santa Lucia” by Teodoro Cottrau and “La Danza” by Rossini.  All of the selections are from the late 19th and early 20th centuries.  Stage direction is by Claire Choquette who brings out all the drama of the situations calling on the vocal and acting ability of the singers which is of a very high level. 

The second part with 7 solos and duets features tenor Logan Wagner and soprano Charlotte Kelso who sing  of their love for each other with a tinge of jealousy at times.  Kelso, a beautiful woman stays in her part throughout, even when she is only present and not singing during Wagner’s solos.  Her accompanists Abe and Sakurako Jayne Abe  and Eric Head provide sometimes fiery piano.

Charlotte Kelso Soprano

The third part has three singers in a love triangle where sometimes love is dying but new love arrives.  Bass Theo Harrah and soprano Shannon Crowley are one couple with tenor Chester Seungyup Han the third member of the triangle who vies for her love.   Accompanists here are Tony Stauffer and Yue Qi Zhang.

All singers and accompanists are already so professional and seasoned that one wonders what else can they learn from the summer program   They have already performed in many operas.  With the Merola winners you will see them on the stage soon many more times.

The program without intermission lasted one hour and 20 minutes.  The last three events of the Summer Merola Festival are two operas, Peter Brook’s reinterpretation of  Bizet’s “Carmen” July 9 and 11 and Richard Strauss’ “Ariadne auf Naxos July 30 and August 1.  The Merola Grand Finale at Davies Symphony Hall featuring all participants is on August 15.  

Tickets 415 864 3330 and more information merola.org.

6th St. Playhouse’s ‘Sister Act’ offers feel-good musical about fake nun

By Woody Weingarten

Nuns, shown here as convent chorus in Sister Act, provide cover for Deloris Van Cartier, who’s fleeing murderous gangsters. Photo by Eric Chazankin.

By WOODY WEINGARTEN

After an astoundingly exciting, fast, feel-good first half of Sister Act, the 21 performers at the 6th St. Playhouse in Santa Rosa couldn’t quite transcend the slightly slower pace in Act II that the script prescribed.

But that was the only visible flaw in the 2½-hour production. In fact, almost every element of the musical-comedy was superlative:

• The smoothly movable set, designed by Laurynn Malilty, was of Broadway quality, better than any seen in the Bay Area in years. Depiction of the inside of a convent was pinpoint perfect, down to the tiniest detail, and all the other backdrops were equally well thought out and constructed.

• Deloris Van Cartier, the role made famous by Whoopi Goldberg in the 1992 Sister Act film as she became a fake nun while hiding from murderous gangsters, is exquisitely filled by Majesty Scott. She’s a quadruple threat who’s obviously mastered singing, acting, comedy, and dancing.

• Costumes co-designed by Barbara Page and Carolyn Bartlett, sensationally ranged from quietly spiritual to in-your-face glitzy. All of them add to a theatergoer’s amusement.

• Tracy Hinman skillfully depicted the Mother Superior, wearing her emotions — from disdain to a loving acceptance — on the sleeves of her habit.

• Choreography by Jorey Cantu guaranteed smiles on the faces of audience members. It featured tons of snappy hand movements and even a low-kicking nun’s chorus line.

• Chase Thompson was amazingly rubber-legged and rubber-armed while dancing as T.J., a thug. It was impossible to not laugh at — and appreciate — his exaggerated, comedic body movements.

• Most folks weren’t likely to leave the Santa Rosa theater singing any of the unfamiliar songs (music by Alan Menken, lyrics by Glenn Slater), despite some of the 19 musical numbers being incredibly bouncy or remarkably melancholy. The eclectic score nevertheless successfully moved the storyline by Bill and Cheri Steinkellner along, silly and predictable as it was.

Majesty Scott portrays hiding lounge singer Deloris Van Cartier. Photo by Eric Chazankin.

• Chorus members were mostly cheery, a contagion that spread throughout the packed audience, and soloists were so strong the crowd reacted with frequent wild applause and occasional screeching. Especially memorable were Andrew Cedeno singing “I Could Be That Guy” as Eddie Souther; Isiah Carter as Curtis Jackson, mobster chieftain (‘When I Find My Baby’); and Hannah Passanisi as Sister Mary Robert (‘The Life I Never Led’) — plus, of course, Majesty Scott as Deloris (the title tune) and Tracy Hinman as Mother Superior (‘Haven’t Got a Prayer”).

• The eight-member band in the pit, led by music director and keyboardist Ginger Beavers, played at just the right level so the sound didn’t overshadow any of the individual singers.

• Director Megan Bartlett, along with stage manager Celina Kegerreis, tracked everything at once during rehearsals, then shattered the chaos by helping each performer be precisely where he/she/they were supposed to be.

Put all those positive talking points together and what do you end up with? An exceptional show that fulfills its promise to entertain and let theatergoers have fun, all the while managing to ignore the constant Breaking News.

Sister Act will run through June 27 at the 6th St. Playhouse, 52 W. 6th St., Santa Rosa. Tickets: $31.95 to $55.95. Info: (707) 523-4185 or boxoffice@6thstreetplayhouse.com.

Sherwood “Woody” Weingarten, a longtime voting member of the San Francisco Bay Area Theater Critics Circle, can be contacted by email at voodee@sbcglobal.net or on his websites, https://woodyweingarten.comand https://vitalitypress.com. His books include Rollercoaster: How a man can survive his partner’s breast cancer, aimed at male caregivers; MysteryDates — How to keep the sizzle in your relationship; The Roving I, a compilation of 70 of his newspaper columns; and Grampy and His Fairyzona Playmates, a whimsical fantasy intended for 6- to 10-year-olds that he co-authored with his then 8-year-old granddaughter.

 

 As You Like It

By Joseph Cillo




I arrived expecting a traditional Shakespeare comedy.

About 20 minutes later, something unexpected happened.

I stopped thinking about Shakespeare.

I was listening to the music, laughing at the jokes and having far more fun than I expected.

By intermission, I wasn’t wondering what Shakespeare meant.

I was wondering when Lady Zen was going to sing again.

Adapted and directed by Evren Odcikin, this production takes one of Shakespeare’s most beloved comedies and gives it fresh energy without losing the heart of the original story.

What I discovered was a production that uses music, movement, humor and strong performances to make Shakespeare feel surprisingly approachable.

The answer was Lady Zen.

I’ve seen plenty of productions that include music.

Usually the songs help bridge scenes or provide atmosphere.

Not here.

Her songs became an essential part of the storytelling.

Each musical number pulled the audience deeper into the emotional world of the play. Her voice carried warmth, humor, soul and mischief. Rather than interrupting the action, the songs expanded it.

More than once I found myself looking forward to the next song as much as the next scene.

Lady Zen’s songs were performances within a performance.

For those unfamiliar with the story, Rosalind is banished from court and escapes into the Forest of Arden disguised as the young Ganymede. There she encounters Orlando, who has been searching for Rosalind without realizing she is standing right in front of him disguised as a young man. Around them swirl lovers, fools, philosophers, exiles and dreamers, all searching for connection, acceptance and happiness.

Fortunately, you don’t need a degree in Shakespeare to enjoy any of it.

The production keeps the story moving, the comedy lands and the relationships remain easy to follow.

Jeunée Simon brings intelligence, confidence and charm to Rosalind, while Adam Magill makes an appealing Orlando. Together they provide the emotional center of the evening and give us two characters worth rooting for.

Another surprise was the set.

Or perhaps more accurately, the lack of one.

There isn’t much scenery.

The production places much of the storytelling burden on the actors, and they respond with abundant physicality, movement and commitment. Through gesture, energy and imagination they create forests, journeys, romances, conflicts and entire emotional landscapes.

The set may be sparse, but the stage never feels empty.

The outdoor setting at Forest Meadows Amphitheatre adds another layer to the experience. As daylight gradually fades and evening settles over the hillside, the Forest of Arden begins to feel surprisingly real.

The combination of live music, natural surroundings and energetic performances creates an atmosphere that is both intimate and inviting.

Whether you arrived as a Shakespeare enthusiast or someone who normally approaches Shakespeare with caution, there was room for you in this Forest of Arden.

The themes of love, identity, acceptance and belonging emerge naturally through the story. They are present throughout the evening, but never delivered with a heavy hand. The production trusts us to discover them for ourselves.

I came expecting Shakespeare. I left remembering the music, the laughter and the people.

As You Like It?

I certainly did.


AS YOU LIKE IT
Marin Shakespeare Company
Forest Meadows Amphitheatre
Dominican University, San Rafael

Now Playing Through July 19

Performance Schedule:
Thursday–Saturday at 7:30 PM
Sunday at 5:00 PM

Running Time:
Approximately 2 hours, 30 minutes including intermission

Tickets & Information:
www.marinshakespeare.org/as-you-like-it


Recommended for audiences who enjoy outdoor theater, live music, strong ensemble performances and Shakespeare that feels fresh, welcoming and thoroughly entertaining.

Merola Summer Program 2026

By Carol Benet

For All Events

Carol Benet

Merola:  The Merola Opera Program is revered in the world of emerging artists aspiring for a career.  This year over 1,500 international contestants applied and 28  were chosen and just started their summer training.  Singers, pianists, coaches, directors arrived in San Francisco and were already placed in performances.

The 2026 Merola Summer Festival started April 1 with recitals by former participants.  Concerts, and two operas, training sessions, master classes and a Grand Finale follow until the program ends August, 2026. 

A recital on June 16 featured well-known opera singer bass-baritone Kyle Ketelsen accompanied by the master pianist Carrie-Ann Matheson who is also the Artistic Director of the Merola program. Six recent Merlini, as the new Merola winners are called, performed a duet solos and a portion of  Puccini’s “Tosca” where Ketelsen sang the villain role of Scarpia to a very talented Soprano Charlotte Kelson as Tosco.  

In the first part of the program  Ketelsen sang three solos by Ravel” and a Mozart duet with Shannon Crowley .  Extremely talented participants, tenor Chester-Seungyup, baritone Paul Jang and tenor Ryan Bryce, also sang solos, duets and after the intermission, they all sang and acted in a very dramatic  excerpt from “Tosca”.  The director of the concert was Claire Choquette and a second piano accompanist Deven Shah are both this year’s Merola winners.

Scheduled for the rest of the summer are another concert, two operas and the Grand Finale. 

On June 25 “L’Anima Napolitana” is a recital of songs from the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries from Napoli.  July 9 and 11 is a rendition of Bizet’s opera by the innovative and famous producer/director Peter Brook’ who rethought  “La Tragédie de Carmen”.  On July 30 and August 1 is the second opera, Richard Strauss’s “Ariadne aux Naxos”. Both operas are performed at the SF Conservatory of Music’s Caroline H. Hume Concert Hall, 50 Oak Street, San Francisco.

And the culmination of the Merola summer program is the very popular Grand Finale on August 15 with conductor William Lang and current Merola participant director Claire Choquette. This takes place at the War Memorial Opera House.

More information on the world famous Merola Summer Festival look at merola.org.

Sympathetic docudrama tracks Japanese Americans interned because of bias

By Woody Weingarten

Bias, here in the form of graffiti, is a major theme of Kintsukurio, an independent docudrama. (Screenshot from Vimeo.)

By WOODY WEINGARTEN

Two ordinary families quietly cringe and join a line to the unknown. They don’t know it yet, but they’ll be penned in and guarded without formal charges or a trial, their activities monitored and severely limited, their private items minimized. For years to come.

Kintsukurio, a sympathetic Ikeibi Films docudrama that personalizes the Japanese internment in the United States during World War II, traces those families and their struggles — struggles against a bias that doesn’t disappear after they’re released.

Roughly 120,000 Japanese were interned in America during World War II by the U.S. government.

In a sense, Donald Trump’s current administration is mirroring the horror of sub-humanizing and incarcerating large blocks of people that the government or his allies are afraid of or simply don’t like. Specifically, in this case, by confining hundreds of thousands of undocumented, brown-skinned people it seeks to illegally deport as soon as possible.

Admittedly, the Nazis did even worse. They imprisoned millions of Jews in various countries, cramming them into the Auschwitz-Birkenau death camp and other forced-labor camps — killing six million innocents, all told.

Confusion is prevalent in long lines that lead to incarceration. (Screenshot from Vimeo.)

Kintsukurio humanizes the Japanese prisoners by focusing on the two familiar family units (including love, hope, and disagreements), albeit with actors who are sometimes stiff. It features thespians most likely unseen before, so the sense of reality becomes easier. Verbal cliches, rather than stopping a viewer, help that sense as well. So does the knowledge that the fictional story virtually replicates real-life tales.

After defining the title as “the Japanese art of repairing broken pottery with gold” to make it stronger, which becomes an overt metaphor, it tracks them from being typical family- and legacy-oriented homebodies through their unpleasant time in confinement (although they can play baseball and dance).

Following their “repatriation,” they discover that anti-Japanese discrimination follows them wherever they go.

The independent feature, which was written and directed by Kerwin Berk and runs two hours and 18 minutes, sharply contrasts a young Japanese male who serves in the U.S. military with those in internment — a soldier who suffers from PTSD, post-traumatic stress disorder, without that diagnosis being available.

In the final analysis, the film is an exercise in determining identity, specifically what it means to be a Japanese American — or, in fact, an anything American.

Kintsukurio isn’t screening in any local theaters, but a Vimeo can be found via www.asianamericanmovies.com

Sherwood “Woody” Weingarten, a longtime voting member of the San Francisco Bay Area Theater Critics Circle, can be contacted by email at voodee@sbcglobal.net or on his websites, https://woodyweingarten.comand https://vitalitypress.com. His books include Rollercoaster: How a man can survive his partner’s breast cancer, aimed at male caregivers; MysteryDates — How to keep the sizzle in your relationship; The Roving I, a compilation of 70 of his newspaper columns; and Grampy and His Fairyzona Playmates, a whimsical fantasy intended for 6- to 10-year-olds that he co-authored with his then 8-year-old granddaughter.

Ain’t Too Proud

By Joseph Cillo



Last night I swam in a sea of Motown classics.

Not just a handful of familiar tunes, but wave after wave of songs that have been part of America’s musical soundtrack for more than half a century. By evening’s end, the audience at Ain’t Too Proud: The Life and Times of The Temptations was on its feet, happily carried along by the music, energy, and heart of the production.

Most people arrive knowing the music. What they may not expect is how compelling the story behind that music can be.


By intermission, I found myself wondering whether there were any Motown classics left unplayed.

Storyline

Ain’t Too Proud follows The Temptations from their humble beginnings in Detroit to the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. Along the way, the group achieves extraordinary success while navigating fame, friendship, conflict, and the pressures that accompany life in the spotlight.

The result is more than a musical biography. It is a story about loyalty, perseverance, and the challenge of staying together when success threatens to pull people apart.

The music is, of course, the evening’s greatest asset.

The hits arrive in rapid succession—My Girl, Get Ready, Just My Imagination, Papa Was a Rollin’ Stone, I Can’t Get Next To You, Cloud Nine, Ball of Confusion, The Way You Do the Things You Do, and many more. Nearly 30 songs are featured during the evening.

What surprised me was not the music—everyone expects that.

What surprised me was the emotional depth behind the songs.

The musical reveals the personal struggles, disappointments, rivalries, and triumphs that shaped one of America’s most successful vocal groups.


The songs never overwhelm the story. Instead, they help tell it.

More than a jukebox musical, Ain’t Too Proud reveals the triumphs, tensions, and enduring friendships behind one of America’s most beloved vocal groups.

The cast captures not only the sound of The Temptations but also the charisma and chemistry that made them legends. The choreography is sharp, energetic, and beautifully synchronized, drawing enthusiastic applause throughout the evening.The audience responded exactly as you might expect. Heads nodded to familiar rhythms. Smiles appeared instantly when favorite songs began. More than a few people quietly sang along.

By final curtain, the crowd was fully invested in both the music and the men who created it.

For Motown fans, the show is a joyful trip down memory lane. For everyone else, it is an entertaining and often moving introduction to one of the most influential groups in popular music history.

As final notes faded and the audience rose for a standing ovation, one thing became clear.

Beneath the music lies a story of friendship, ambition, loyalty, and perseverance. Those themes resonate today just as strongly as they did when The Temptations first stepped onto a Detroit stage more than 60 years ago.


You may come for the music — but you may also leave remembering the men behind it.

The Temptations By the Numbers

Founded: 1961 in Detroit
Official Members Since 1961: 27
Original Members: 5
Surviving Original Member: Otis Williams
Top Ten Hits: 42
Number One Singles: 14
Grammy Awards: 4
Rock & Roll Hall of Fame: 1989
Years Performing: 65+

Bottom Line

Filled with iconic songs, dynamic choreography, strong performances, and genuine emotional resonance, Ain’t Too Proud delivers an evening that is both entertaining and unexpectedly moving.

Highly Recommended.

How to See It / Get Tickets

Ain’t Too Proud: The Life and Times of The Temptations
June 12–28
Field of Dreams
Sonoma, California
Rating: PG-13

Transcendence Theatre Company
(877) 424-1414
transcendencetheatre.org


Woman’s monologue at The Marsh Berkeley about runaway lacks intensity

By Woody Weingarten

 

 

 

As Carol Klyce performs at The Marsh Berkeley, a garment from her childhood, the only memento she still has, hangs behind her in this screenshot.

By WOODY WEINGARTEN

Shortly after her mother dies of ovarian cancer, her father, a drunk, vanishes into the ozone. Not that much later, she’s forcibly separated her from her four siblings.

“Sometimes,” Carole Klyce admits, “I would just run into the woods and scream and cry.”

The pain and fear are too much. So she runs away.

From a group foster home this time. And next, when the state erroneously labels her an incorrigible troublemaker and starts the paperwork to put her in a mental institution, she runs away.

She runs away from a juvenile correction facility, too.

Into the clutches of a child molester. Into the employ of the Mafia.

And she runs away from both of them as well.

Photograph of Carole Klyce as she is today (by Cynthia Smalley).

Her monologue at The Marsh Berkeley reveals an endless need as a teenage runaway to change her name, her appearance, her skills. She even needs to masquerade as a boy.

Sounds like the life-fodder for a fascinating, emotional, one-person show, doesn’t it? Well, despite Klyce doing her best, her opening night merges all those elements but somehow leaves out the inherent tension, the intensity, the melodrama.

Klyce and director Deb Fink neglect to give different weights to differing story elements. The memoir becomes as exciting as if the playwright/performer were reading an elongated list of streaming channels.

Flight Risk, which runs through June 20, holds promise. But the two-hour, intermission-less show could be pared at least 30 minutes, maybe more, including irrelevant, unnecessary references to JFK and other tangential items. That at least might ensure the monologue not feeling like one incredibly long run-on sentence.

Much more attention also needs to be given the pacing and pitch. And to potential sequences of poignancy, like when she takes charge of her nuclear family at age 12 (including care and feeding of her dying mother), and when she develops a close relationship with her grandfather (“my best friend”), who also dies.

The show might well amplify some of her life’s lowlights sandwiched between a hopeful static-laden recording of “Tomorrow” from Annie and the playwright-performer’s 18th birthday party. It’s certainly important to be able to figure out where she is when she’s bouncing from one place to another (“I can’t remember the last time I took a bath in a real bathtub.”).

Klyce, now a mother of three, grandmother of four, deserves credit for her bravery, for being honest and vulnerable in a show that details six of her teenage years that are vastly more horrific than that of your average kid.

One Saturday evening audience, clearly packed with her friends and supporters, distinctly veered from any negative assessment, however, mildly gasping and otherwise reacting to moments of imminent physical or mental danger or angst, chuckling at almost every gag line or comedic movement, and giving a wrinkled, weathered Klyce a rousing ovation as she bowed.

Flight Risk will run at the Marsh Berkeley, 2120 Allston Way, Berkeley, through June 20. Tickets: $25 to $35; reserved seats, $50 or $100; plus $3 convenience fee per ticket. Info: 425-282-3055 or boxoffice@themarsh.org.

Sherwood “Woody” Weingarten, a longtime voting member of the San Francisco Bay Area Theater Critics Circle, can be contacted by email at voodee@sbcglobal.net or on his websites, https://woodyweingarten.comand https://vitalitypress.com. His books include Rollercoaster: How a man can survive his partner’s breast cancer, aimed at male caregivers; MysteryDates — How to keep the sizzle in your relationship; The Roving I, a compilation of 70 of his newspaper columns; and Grampy and His Fairyzona Playmates, a whimsical fantasy intended for 6- to 10-year-olds that he co-authored with his then 8-year-old granddaughter.

Opera Parallèle’s “Doubt” at Presidio Theatre

By Carol Benet

“Doubt” at Opera Parallèle

Carol Benet

One of the highlights of classical music in the San Francisco Bay is Nicole Paiement’s Opera Parallèle that since 2007 has created brilliant operas complete with orchestras, minimal sets, lighting, sound — all the attributes of the grand opera but in smaller venues.  Opera Parallèle is dedicated to new and exciting works.

Their production that appeared the last three days of May 2026 at the beautiful Presidio Theatre was “Doubt” a reimagining of the original Broadway hit play that became a movie and a grand opera.  It was to have taken place in 1964 in a Catholic school with “doubts” about what really happened between a priest and the school’s only black student.  

With only four characters for the chamber opera with libretto written by John Patrick Shanley, each one has their opinions about the facts and only “doubt” remains as the conclusion.  The date predates all the publicity about abuses within the church that have filled the news and closed parishes worldwide ever since.  So the current audience has that news in mind when witnessing this work making it even more complex.

The composer Douglas J. Cuomo, well-known for his concert, theater, opera, television and film scores, writes a gorgeous work with a nod to jazz rhythms at times but is mainly  contemporary classical music.  It is interesting that among OP’s Honorary Board Members are Philip Glass and Jake Heggie, two  masters contemporary opera.  An  excellent  orchestra of 13 qualified musicians in this performance are placed on the stage to the right of of the action with Nicole Paiement as conductor.

The concept for the set was conceived by the director Brian Staufenbiel.  It represents the interior of a church with gothic framed windows from which the characters enter and from which Father Flynn (Matthew Worth) gives his sermons.  We, the audience are meant to be seated in the nave of the church and with clever execution of video slides portraying the church interior, the offices, surrounding buildings, birds and ocean.  Floating feathers highlight one of Father Flynn’s parables about the dangers of gossiping that becomes like feathers that can not be put back into the slashed pillow from which they come. The audience feels as if there are in the middle of the action, something that Staufenbiel’s production wants to achieve so that we all have our “doubts” during and even after the play.

A rigid Sister Aloysius (Roslyn Jones, former Adler Fellow of the San Francisco Opera) has imagined a scenario where Father Flynn has given the school’s only black student some wine from his chalice and who knows what happens after that.  All doubtful scenarios are part of the sister’s imagination.

Sister James (Naomi Steele) listens to her diatribes and does not agree but  is afraid to challenge her authority.  An interview with Father Flynn becomes fiery and the music fits all occasions.  The boy’s mother (Deborah Nansteel) comes and begs that he not be expelled for  there are only a few months to the end of the school year for if ihe is her  violent husband might kill the boy.   In 10 short scenes the intrigue evolves and Father Flynn’s eventual placement is described.  Yet we all are left with “doubts”.

Nicole Paiement conducts the fine orchestra.  She is the genius behind the entire Opera Parallèle.  The 2026-2027 season has been announced  with premiers of “Salt & Sea” November 14-21, 2026:  “The Diving Bell and the Butterfly, March 11-14. 2027; “Taking Up Serpents”, May 2027.

For more information go to Operaparallele.org